At the latest from the
19th century on, the following two general principles have been adduced
to explain linguistic variation and, especially, change at all levels:
- Principle of least effort: Maximum economy is a requirement facilitating use of linguistic units for the speaker.
- Principle of maximum distinctiveness: Maximum clarity is a requirement facilitating use of linguistic units for the hearer.
These two principlies are permanently antagonistic; in every individual
case, one wins over the other. Adducing either of them to explain a
particular phenomenon is therefore gratuitous. They may be useful for
linguistic description, but are useless for explanation. (Horn 2008,
CIL 18)